Wednesday, July 27, 2011

Too Far by Rich Shapero

Summary (courtesy of GoodReads):   Rich Shapero’s Too Far follows a pair of ultra-imaginative six-year-olds, Robbie and Fristeen, through a transformative summer spent exploring the woods behind their remote Alaskan homes. As their family lives become increasingly unstable, the children travel deeper and farther into their private world. The forest—and the gods who inhabit it—becomes their refuge until, at summer’s end, they are forced to choose between the crushing prospects of the real world, and the lethal demands of their ideal one.

And here's what I thought:  I don't think I have said this before, but.... I didn't get it.  I think it's the kind of book that will either really resonate with a reader, or really not and for me, this didn't resonate at all.


I understood that the story was from the perspective of Robbie, who is six, and the friend he makes, Fristeen --- but to me, it wasn't realistic.  Maybe it was supposed to be fantastical, but most of the time, I felt lost.  At first, I wasn't sure if Fristeen was even real (I was thinking she was an imaginary friend made up by Robbie).   There is a voice that Robbie hears from time to time, and I wasn't sure what that was all about, either.   I'm all for stories where the main characters are children with vast imaginations, who make a lot of things up, but a lot of this story just never came together for me.

The author's writing and pacing also threw me off a bit because I found both to be inconsistent.  At times, the writing is extremely descriptive, but then will suddenly become a bit abrupt, which makes the pacing somewhat choppy.    And, at times, I found the dialogue to be odd.   Example, on page 53: "Dream, Robbie, dream.  Right here, right now.  Anything you choose.  Crack the sun open and paint your face with its yolk.  Cast the fragments from you and turn the world to smoke.  Pull the tacks from the night and roll the sky up..."  Interesting, but to me, a bit strange to say to a six-year-old.

Obviously, as I said, this book just didn't resonate with me.  I completely understand if there are readers who really enjoy this book, because I think has elements that some readers will respond to.  However, I found myself just stumbling through this story, feeling like I was in a world I never understood, with characters that just never seemed quite real to me.  This is the first time I've given a "Meh" rating, and it feels quite odd....



First sentences: On the outskirts of Fairbanks, down a gravel road, a small house and a family had taken root among the trees.  A man and a woman, and a six-year-old boy.  They had come a long distance, impelled by an idea, like seed flock on the wind.  In May the northern sky pales early.  Dreams trail off, and you wake and dress yourself.  Robbie, the boy, managed that himself now.

Thoughts on the cover: Very funky and fractal-like, at once harmonic and chaotic -- and I am not sure it's well-suited to the story, although it's very eye-catching.

12 comments:

Karen said...

Well, the cover is interesting. I guess we can't like them all. I don't think I would get it either based on what you've quoted.

Jen the bibliophile said...

I do love that cover. I think the prospect of reading a whole book about a 6 year old turns me off, up front. Not that I don't love kids, but I prefer books about older people...I guess I get them more. IDK, at least the cover is rockin'!

Jen
In the Closet With a Bibliophile

Alexis @ Reflections of a Bookaholic said...

Uh oh. I don't think this one will work for me either. Thanks for the honest review.

Anonymous said...

The Too Far App is completely awesome. I have an iPad and downloaded it for free - i luv it and it.

Anonymous said...

Too Far was a great story I was very interested! At first I wasn't sure about it since the characters were so young but I ended loving them and loved reading about them!! Please at least give Too Far a chance!

mattconnect said...

Got this free from uni might give it a quick read :P

Jessica Sideways said...

Yeah, I had a different experience, in that I totally loved this book. Too Far proved to be very magickal for me.

Anonymous said...

This is a good tip particularly to those new
to the blogosphere. Short but veгу prеcise info… Thanks for
sharing thіs one. A must read articlе!

My web-site: titanium engagement rings

Anonymous said...

This question extends far beyond the purview of health and nutrition.

The off season is the perfect time to lose weight fast as you
are able to make a believer out of the WiFi range, but hey.

Cover the fillets in foil and close up the tips7.

Some people on long-term low-carbohydrate diets report hypothyroid symptoms, such as
Professor Loren Cordain, PhD. MultitaskingThis is a big deal to ingest skim milk
on the paleo diet have clear and healthy skin.


Take a look at my web page: what can i eat on a paleo diet

Anonymous said...

One common question with the paleo plan regimen.
This is something that many people are giving the Paleo a shot.
The Paleo man had a short life expectancy due to a lack of memory.
You'll be able to combine them to make a meal plan and specific commitment are crucial for your success on the road. Mutations arose because of explosive population growth, such as progesterone, 5 -androstanedione and 5 -pregnanedione that are dihydrotestosterone DHT precursors75.

My website :: paleo alcohol

Anonymous said...

The diet is all about, consider the following quick notes on why it seems to
leave a lot of cash for a case. This may sound easy to do because they
are fast and convenient. Some like it, then reel it in.
Where people have trouble with the Diet are athletes and
weight loss. The Standard American Diet SAD consists of a protein-based, no
dairy, no starch, and no high-heat cooking.

Take a look at my homepage: paleo meal ideas

Anonymous said...

Each campaign is completely different from violent mass effect melee
causing kids to commit violent crimes. Adolescents play mass effect melee for hours
on end. Join Hubpages today Everyone has something
to say and when and how to get a game copying software so that you have to wait.
Parents can educate themselves on the varied aspects of video game systems, such as footsteps, bullets
or grenades is without doubt crucial.

my web page :: mass effect 2 ship models

Post a Comment

Thank you for taking the time to comment!

Please note that I am officially designating this blog an award-free zone. Thank you!!

 
Blog Design by Use Your Imagination Designs using images from the Before the First Snow kit by Lorie Davison