And here's what I thought: I had been reading other bloggers' reviews of this book and they seemed pretty varied between liking this book, and not really loving it. So, I decided to pick it up and give it a try (the baeutiful book cover was also part of the allure). Of course, I had to wait for it (I was on the holds list at our library). What I found was a good story, although one that had a few flaws in it. I'm not going to have any spoilers here, and you can see the summary of what the book's about above. Overall, I actually liked the story. Claire isn't a perfect character, and has moments of being a little.... whiny. However, I think she's pretty realistic for a 16 year-old who's just figuring out she's going to be in for some big changes. She's not happy about it, and she'd much rather concentrate her energy on Matthew --- who, of course, happens to be the son of a major-league jerk, and the enemy of her mother's pack. I felt that the author did a good job of adding some mystery into the story, and making it hard to tell at times who the rogue werewolf is. I also like how Christine Johnson made the pack all-female, and how being a werewolf wasn't seen as a curse at all, but as a gift from the Goddess. I suppose I could do a little paragraph here about female-power, and monthly curses....but I won't. I know you're glad I didn't.
The flaws I found in the book weren't big enough to keep me from turning the pages. However, there were a few "Huh?" moments --- like, in this world werewolves are known to exist, but Claire's mom's pack feels the need to keep everything a big secret. I mean, one bad rogue doesn't make an entire group evil. But then again, Matthew's dad is a fanatic; I don't think he'd listen to reason. He probably hates werewolves so much because he knows he can never be one. Is this wolf-envy? But I digress. Overall, even though this story wasn't perfect, it had enough elements that I enjoyed that I wanted to keep reading.
If you'd like to read some other well-written reviews of this book, please visit: The Book Smugglers, The Story Siren, and The Ninja Librarian.
2 comments:
I absolutely cannot wait to read this! I'm glad the MC is realistic; it drives me nuts when 16 year olds in novels act 26 instead. Great review!
Your review made me giggle. (the part about female power and monthly curses)
I had no expectations with this book so I was pleasently suprised by how good the story was. I agree there were flaws, but it was a rather original story.
(I think you would like nightshade)
Post a Comment
Thank you for taking the time to comment!
Please note that I am officially designating this blog an award-free zone. Thank you!!